Shabana gives ‘royal ditch’ to Muslim women; didn’t turn up at their national convention
By Kulsum Mustafa for TwoCircles.net,
Lucknow: Cine actor, former Member of Parliament, and one projected by the media as a strong supporter of women and human rights, Shabana Azmi gave a royal ditch to hundreds of Muslim women when she failed to honor her commitment to be the chief guest at the third national convention of Bhartiya Muslim Mahila Andolan (BMMA) held in Lucknow on 11th October.
Showing total disregard for all norms and tradition Shabana did not even show the basic courtesy of informing her host that she was not coming. The BMMA members, who had gone to receive her at the Amausi airport, got a rude shock when they discovered that Shabana was not on the Mumbai-Lucknow flight on which she had been booked. Deeply concerned about her well-being they called her up. After many futile attempts Shabana picked up the phone. Sans any regret or explanation she simply told them that she had cancelled her programme for Lucknow.

Shabana Azmi with children of Kaifi Azmi School at her village in Azamgarh in Nov 2008. PTI photo
Back at the venue red faced, the organizers had to tell the media and the public, both of whom had been waiting for Shabana in the sultry heat all afternoon that madam was not coming.
The organizers explained how it was only after several e-mails, telephone calls, and personal meetings that Shabana had finally consented to attend the convention.
“Only when she gave us her acceptance to attend that we printed her name on the invite. We sent her air tickets, booked her a room at a five star hotel in Lucknow and were happily awaiting her arrival when we learnt that she was not coming,” Noorjahan, BMMA member conducting the programme told the audience.
“We are deeply unhappy about this let down. But we were never more convinced than now that this movement for our rights will have to be run on our own strength. BMMA poor, semi literate volunteers will carry it forward. We should not depend on any celebrity for help, for leadership,” is how Noorjahan described Shabana’s irresponsible behavior.
Terming it as a ‘hadsa’ (grave mishap) she said that BMMA volunteers were strong enough to carry on with this great mission and ensure that their dream of a more equal world for Muslim community became a reality.
Though Shabana did temporarily disappoint the hundreds of women who had gathered from across 15 states of India at the venue to hear her, but she has caused herself more permanent harm by her callous attitude towards a very important section of society. For someone who just a few months back shook the whole country by her statement that Indian democracy is unfair to Muslims and that it makes only “token gestures” instead of addressing the real issues Shabana has shown that she is no better than those who have failed to support Muslim community. Shabana not only let down her community despite being a woman she let down so many women. The lady has shown total disregard for the cause that she claims to uphold and also trampled upon public sentiments. These can sound a death-knell for any one in public life.
“Shabana’s stinging attack on the country’s polity sounds so hollow now. She seems to cry foul only when she or her own kith and kin are affected. This is total hypocrisy,” said a BMMA office bearer in anger and disgust.
Asserting that Indian Muslims are given an unfair deal in India Shabana had even gone as far as to accuse the Muslim leadership of inefficient handling of community sentiments and called it a failure to project ‘true Islam.’
When Shabana got a chance of sharing the ‘real’ issues with the masses she failed to do so. Shabana’s anger only boils when she allegedly is not able to buy a flat in Mumbai. She created media hype about it suggesting that the root cause was the fact that she was a Muslim.
She contradicts herself when she claims before the whole world that she has led a ‘liberal, bohemian life and religion played no part in her family.
Shabana must clear the cobwebs of confusion about her personal life before she attempts to address the problems of the community.
Is she a ‘victim of discrimination?” Or victim of circumstances?
FREE REPRINTS
Unless otherwise noted, you can republish our articles for free. You just have to credit TwoCircles.net and link it back to us, and you can’t edit our material or sell it separately. (We're licensed under Creative Commons, which provides the legal details.). For publishing TwoCircles.net photos please contact info@twocircles.net.




It is unfair for the author
It is unfair for the author to pass value judgments. Ms Azmi is a well known crusader of human rights. Her inability to make it to a function should not invite such harsh comments, which smell of a personal bias.
Shabana's royal ditch to Muslim women
There is neither any personal bias nor any value judgement done in this article. The organizer's (BMMA) members have been quoted to support the story angle. After having spent over two decades in the field of journalism I think I know what I am writing.
There is a difference in being a known crusader of human rights and really being one, I hope u understand the difference. Shabana had a chance to prove that she supports minority women struggle to come free of the bondage and sadly she missed it. The fact that she kept the organizers in the dark about her programme cancellation just shows how responsible and sensitive she is to such issues.
Kulsum Talha,
it doesn't matter how long
it doesn't matter how long you have been into any field. yellow journalism should not be encouraged.My simple question is why the organisation has asked Shabana to come if they already had predisposed negative mind-set. They should have asked some other personality who is ideal and matches with the values and disposed programme.
Again, who is real human rights crusader people do not need any organisation to illustrate. If she was not true Human rights crusader then why did the organisation send the invite to her? I am not at all in favour of Shabana on my grounds but it does not give me liberty to impose my personal opinion about her. this is sheer misleading. pls give facts as it is. we don't need any entertainments based on others understanding
i found this report and
i found this report and backing illustration on her personal life is not justifiable. It appears as if writer has some personal problem with Shabana. Nobody can judge how one should live life. U can not pose in negative sense that she is bohemian and liberal as if it is wrong. Moreover, purpose of the report is to give facts only and let the people think on that.pls, dont add spic to that. it will ruin the whole purpose.
She did not turn up and u start rebuking her . If she is irresponsible one should not forget his/her responsibility and dignity.
two circle is doing good job in sense to give updates of happening on the Muslims issues but don't not incorporate value judgment and subjective elements.. it will ruin the whole purpose.
do not depend on others
Ms Kulum Mustafa is able to bring right words what is needed. We should not depend on others.
Even in countries like Germany woman get almost 23% less salary on grounds of their gender. German industry you will hardly find woman in top management. So it is the German woman who have to protest for their equal rights.
I will try my best to get good postion for Indians in Germany. We have to learn that "no culture can survive if it attempts to be exclusive" Gandhiji pointed out to the fact that British Raj people never learnt to mix with Indian society, culture and language. Indian muslims did.
BMMA, i think does not
BMMA, i think does not understands what a Muslim is, thats the reason they have called shabana azmi. shabana azmi, celebrates, Hindu festivals, she supports sodomites, and, many more things. what can anyone expect from a person like that.
BMMA/Ghazi
So she supports Hindu festivals, sodomites.. Because of that you say "what one can expect from a person like that"?
What is wrong in supporting Hindu festivals? What is wrong in supporting sodomites? Are nt they also children of God? Or does Allah segregate His childrten as sodomites and non-sodomites?
Muslims Faith
First of all Allah is not a Human being, so the attributes of Father and Children relationship don't apply to Allah.
Allah is the Creator, sustainer of all beings. So when Allah is the creator, its Allah's law that needs to be followed, which has been mentioned in the Holy Quran and practiced by our beloved Prophet Muhammad(May peace and mercy of Allah be upon him).
As for sodomites are concerned they are a social evil.
Its mentioned in the quran regarding the sodomites and the destruction of their town, "So when Our Commandment came, We turned them upside down, and rained on them stones of sijjil mandud (piled up, baked clay); marked from your Lord, and it is not far from the wrong-doers.” (The Holy Quran Hud; 82-83)
Islam is against this lewd concept, and any support for these people is unislamic.
Now coming to supporting Hindu festivals. Allah is the creator, Allah has no partners, and i am sure that you are aware that Islam is against idol worship as well. Now when our Holy prophet Conquered Makkah through the Help Allah, the first thing he did was to destroy all the idols that were placed inside the Kaabah(Black stone at Makkah).
In all Hindu festivals one bows in front of the idol Deities, which means that you are considering them as your creator, or at least you are ascribing partners with Allah, and according to Islam, this is sufficient for one to be out of Islam. And Shabana Azmi and the likes of her have done this publicly so many times, which means Public display of apostasy.
And for a Muslim, ones Faith is the most important thing, its far greater to him/her than any other thing. So Organisations, which calls itself as either Muslim or Islamic should be aware of these facts, before they Invite someone with a Muslim name as their Guest or leader.
Shabana as a chief guest for a muslim org. is a poor choice.
Assalamualaikum
Jazakallah for your reply.Muslims should focus on islam while replying to non muslims comments.May ALLAH reward you for doing Dawah Work which unfortunately very few of us is doing.
w/salam
Post new comment