Why S M Mushrif’s book “Who Killed Karkare?” not discussed in media
Submitted by admin3 on 6 January 2010 - 12:48pm
By Mohd Ziyallah Khan,
To tell a truth in front of a tyrant ruler is the biggest crusade in the sight of Lord. And perhaps, this saying sounds so true to Mr. S M Mushrif (retired IPS officer – former IGP Maharashtra) when he wrote his book ‘Who killed Karkare?’ published a couple of months back. Ironically, despite all the truth he has managed to jot down in his daring work, he couldn’t get the kind of coverage or response in the Media.
The sort of debate or discussion it should spark off in the market sounds missing though, the reasons are obvious, which he himself disclosed in his recent visit to Nagpur on 2nd and 3rd January 2010 in a conference organised by Bahujan Sangarsh Samiti Nagpur Chapter.
He said that 20-25 different journalists from the various big and small media houses – both the print and electronic – which interviewed him on 28th October 2009 at his Pune residence, but nothing really appeared the following day, except in small time newspapers of the city. His work was totally kept under the carpet; nobody really cared to debate or discuss it in public domain, thanks to the kind of pressure the Saffron brigade has created on the media industry. So one can imagine the fear in which they dwell these days. To this point Mushrif added a humor saying, “the saffron elements happen to be the real terrorist, but with my book they seems to be terrorized, so in this way I now call myself a more bigger terrorist than them”.
The most interesting speech in the two-day program of Bahujan Sangarsh Samiti, was in the symposium on ‘Hindu Nation and Bahujan Society’ (Bahujan Society is referred to the non-Brahmin communities, including Muslims, Christians, Sikh, Dalits, OBC’s etc). In his speech, Mr Mushrif said that the real trouble before the anti-national elements (saffron groups) were the true nationalist people like Karkare, Salaskar, Kamte etc, who managed to find the real culprit behind the series of bomb blasts executed in various places including, Malegaon, Nanded and Parbhani etc. The two laptops recovered by Karkare after Sadhvi Pragya’s arrest disclosed, how the Hindu terror network was responsible for the series of bomb blasts carried out, making Muslim innocent youths responsible for the same.
The laptop recovered had ample of information about how the Hindu terror group materialized this anti-national activities using people and groups of different expertise and resource. These groups of men included some high profile industrialists, politicians, media professionals, historians, academicians and so on. This new nexus coming into light was well exposed by our real hero, the ATS Chief, Hemant Karkare. This man made a promise to himself that he will leave no stone unturned to let the world know the truth. However, before he could do this, he was knocked out of this mortal world in a very mysterious fashion during the 26/11 Mumbai attack.
According to Mushrif, the elimination of Karkare was nothing but an innovative way of getting rid of a person who was likely to expose the anti-national elements which is nothing but the saffron brigade. This innovative way is – certainly killing people like Karkare under the shadow of some operation like 26/11, so it was a good team work between the so called Lashkar men and the saffron elements.
According to Mushrif, the IB was well informed about the LeT men hatching a plan to attack the Taj, they had been knowing this fact since 18th November 2008, but unfortunately, they never passed on this information to the Navy or to the Mumbai police, rather they preferred to give it to the coast guard which has nothing to do with the internal security. So it was nothing but efforts done too little too late, failing thus to avert this attack. The IB despite being informed about the movement of the boat carrying the men with lethal weapons remained tongue tied. Earlier the IB was provided with 35 different suspicious cell no’s by the RAW, the same numbers used during those 72 hours of terror in Mumbai, including many ISD calls and only one call made in Mumbai, just before the death of Karkare. In this way Hemant Karkare was killed by the men as per the directions of the saffron elements, while the message went to the masses was, ‘LeT men killed him’.
According to Mushrif, he had found 11 stark contrasting elements in two operations. The Taj-Oberoy-Trident was completely different from the one at Cama and Rangbhavan lanes. How can same people be at two different places at the same time? Also, he came across so many loopholes, in the 26/11 investigation. Sr. IAS officer Rangari told Times of India, Mumbai edition that during the attack at CST, out of 35 CCTV cameras, 16 were shut down at that particular day for no valid reason. The SIM recovered at CST station of the terrorist belonged to a person based at Satara (a city in Maharashtra), the police investigation was intervened in the midst of the due process, and this owner of the SIM was never brought to books. The lady beside the coastal area identified these men who came from boat, and was the eyewitness to the massacre perpetrated at Taj in the broad daylight, but was soon forced to leave for US.
The interesting remark made by Mr. Mushrif at the end of his speech was, that the IB in India is worst than any RSS Shakha, and that if these men who happen to be custodians of our security and who remain hand in glove with the enemies of our society, then its time to stand up for a new revolution.
(The writer is a freelancer and media activist based in Nagpur, can be contacted at writeziya@gmail.com)
Link:
FREE REPRINTS
Unless otherwise noted, you can republish our articles for free. You just have to credit TwoCircles.net and link it back to us, and you can’t edit our material or sell it separately. (We're licensed under Creative Commons, which provides the legal details.). For publishing TwoCircles.net photos please contact info@twocircles.net.
BJP KILLED KARKARE.
BJP KILLED KARKARE.
Conspiracy Theories and Religion
Gentlemen,
1. I am a first time visitor and I was so impressed by Dr Azad's thoughts on being a Muslim and an Indian simultaneously. Clearly, there was no conflict in his mind about his identity. To my interpretation, his being a patriotic Indian did not hinder in any way his being a devout Muslim or vice-versa and he was equally proud of being both. If only every citizen of the country could imbibe his thinking. Being a citizen of India has nothing to do with your religion; not one religion or religious group can claim exclusive rights of claiming the heritage and culture of the country. Every religion has contributed to India's rich culture and heritage. Now for some hard hitting facts.
2. Every religion has some fanatics who associate themselves with it and attempt to justify the use of violence in furthering the cause of religion. The agenda of the LTTE was not overtly religious yet no one can deny that that there were strong religious undertones to their fight against the Sinhalas. The ruffians of Bajrang Dal and its clones are equally detestable. The Khalistani outfits comprised almost exclusively of Sikhs although there were reports of some Hindus joining it later for the money. The activities of Zionist terrorists in Israel are well known. Amongst Christians you could count the IRA, Ku Klux Klan etc to name a few. Al Qaeda, LeT, HuM/HUJI are some of the terrorist outfits who claim to be Muslims. The point I am trying to make is that there will always be a fringe group of extremists who will resort to violence in the name of religion. Does that make all these great religions any less great or does it make all followers of a particular religion evil men? We must not commit the folly of generalising human traits based on their religions.
3. Coming to more specific issues. The support of Pakistan to terrorist groups spewing violence in Kashmir is real. It is also a fact that these groups rely in a major way on religion to motivate their cadres. There has to be some inspiration for a person to blow himself up. Sadly, this inspiration is derived from the notion of fighting a holy war or Jihad for Islam. I always thought that Islam won over more people by preaching love and brotherhood rather than by forcing people by the sword. Anyway, as I mentioned earlier, these are fringe groups and do not reflect the views of majority of the people.
4. The attacks on Mumbai were, in fact, carried out by a group of LeT terrorists from Pakistan. You may not believe this but I speak from first hand experience. Every day we get enough evidence which points to the collusion of the Pakistani establishment in fomenting trouble in India. Events have turned a full cycle and Pakistan is facing the brunt of terrorists they nurtured to further their national objectives in India and Afghanistan. Coming back to Mumbai, even if all the terrorists who launched the attack were born Muslims, did they discredit Islam? I don't think so. They discredited their families, their mentors and their upbringing. Apart from their handlers and masters in Pakistan, no one else should feel guilty or need to offer an apology or justification.
5. Remember 9/11. There was a theory being circulated that the CIA/FBI orchestrated the attacks and controlled demolitions brought down the buildings rather than the jets slamming into them. Remember the assassination of JFK? There was another conspiracy theory there. Mumbai - 26/11 or Batala House, alternative versions of events will always exist. Now do we exorcise people who voice these suspicions or do we need to call them names? No, absolutely not. These people are simply exercising their innate abilities to reason. If someone wants to prove such theories wrong they should come out with facts and figures rather than indulge in name calling.
6. Another important point - that of creating mass hysteria by using tragic events in history. Remember the events before and after the Babri Masjid demolition? The audio cassettes of Ritambhara and Uma Bharti that spewed venom in the garb of religious and nationalistic rhetoric? The clanging of steel plates all over the towns and cities? The call "Islam khatre mein hai"? It was easy to believe such vituperative rhetoric. History is replete with examples of manipulative villains mobilising hordes of innocent people by attacking their weakness to believe. We must not let that happen again. So, every theory, every version should be taken at face value and we should not let emotions get the better of our judgement.
7. One last point. Our leaders harp on national integration. What steps have they taken to further this cause? They have paid only lip service to this important issue. One small step that can be taken by the society is to celebrate our religions together. A Muslim friend told me that I, being a non-Muslim, am not forbidden to enter a mosque to witness how Namaaz is collectively offered. I never went to a mosque. I wonder how many non-Muslims have ever been to a mosque or how many Muslims have been to a Gurudwara/temple or church to witness how other people offer their prayers. You don't have to believe in their Gods, its just understanding their faith that allows you to cohabit this country in a better way. We can start by sharing our meals on our festivals keeping each other's sensitivities in mind.
8. I speak from the heart. I have no reason to be apologetic about anything.
JAI HIND
people who believe in Laws of Manu cannot think rationaly
Being an Ambedkarite and Periyar follower i am not at all surprised at the bigotry of these Manuvadies. Instead of replying point by point on the issues raised by the Former IG of police this fellow simply spitted venom. Actually we bahujan samaj people whether muslims chriastians or hindu untouchables are not paying heed to our own media which is just dying. www.dalitvoice.org and several other muslim dalit journals are doing great jobs. please support our media
Giri...........
I am surprised how a cencer like Giri has not responded to this. May be because it's hard to digest the truth....
No, it is unwise to think why a dog barks without reason.
I don't waste time on reports or books like this whose only purpose is to bash anything as hindu conspiracy. The writer wants to gain sympathy from his fellow islamists and has some agenda. These are the people who see the terror bombing in Pakistans and say RAW is supporting Taliban in those suicide attacks. Better laugh at those heartily than comment on some silly musing.
I am ashamed of Giri calling himself India
Giri,
I am ashamed of calling myself Indian if you are accepted as one. To you anything which feels as 'balm' on your shameless ego is a word of god. Nobody has pointed finger on RAW and Taliban but you invoke them because you accept the blame. May be your mental discontinuities make it so subconciously!!
Giri...... A CANCER
Then possibly you believe books written by arun shourie and fascist sangh parivar or say hegdevar.
No wonder for diseases like you any book of truth will be a waste of time.
I can't believe someone who says a book on national hero Karkare is waste of time but yes a sangh parivar fascist can always say this.
But think again if people can believe an epic written by a dacoit, then i think it shoul'nt be hard to believe a book written on truth by a true indian; a true indian not a self claimed patriot.
could not be more true
@ Anonymous,
Your comments are apt and well deserved. Giri.... or people like him are a cencer to humanity. Being from India, it makes us more difficult. Lets carry the 'Light' to the unassuming instead of committed blind like Giri. You can awaken a sleeping person and not ......
Did you read?
Did you read book on Islam by Ibn Warraq. Well i read it. Do you you think you can read the book? If you cannot, then i rest my case.
Read but could not comprehend due to hypocratic mentality
Giri,
You must have read ibne Warraq but could not comprehend it because your eyes are closed to truth. Why on this earth you think people must have read a book which 'Giri' might do?
What do you think of yourself??
Book on islam
As usual, you are way off target when you write and you always talk in air. Google and you find out who Ibn Warraq and his book on islam is? will you be able to read? Anyway there is no need for someone to poke inbetween our conversation. I was not addressing you.
TCN is not your HUF father's private property, Giri.
@ Giri,
TCN is not your private property under HUF disriminations. You think as if only you have information. Many informed people know about ibnE Warraq and to your worries, I too am among them. You thought a ibnE Warraq or thousands of them are aid for your smear campaign on Islam, but you need to be more dedicated to achieve anything. Nothing more to write for a non-entity like you.
Great Service to India by S M Mushrif
The book should have been released spontaniosly throughout country like the book of Aziz Burney.
However it is the responsibility of the muslim civil society to make it happening in India by organising the programs on the book--Who Killed Karkare. Mr S M Mushrif has done his job briliantly now the ball is in the hands of our community leaders shedding away the misconceptions from the minds of general people.
Permanent reaction to Jehadi Terrorist Attack
The Permanent reaction to Jehadi Terrorist Attack in India is as under:-
- Politicians will say that the killers were not Muslims as no religion teaches violence .
- Secularist will blame it on US middle east policy.
-Leftist will blame anti-Islamic policies of West.
- KNOWLEDGABLE MUSLIM APOLOGISTS WILL USE TAQIYYA
-Muslim NGOs will announce that the perpetrators had hijacked islam..
-Media favourite Muslims will appear on LIVE TV and say islam is a religion of peace and blame the massacre on the “militant heretic sect of Wahabis”.
- BRAIN WASHED MUSLIM UMMA WILL BLAME THE JEWS/ RSS / VHP etc.
The BOOK by Mr. S M Mushrif is TAQIYYA by MUSLIM APOLOGIST- a bundle of lies and conjunctures. Even TCN is an organ of TAQIYYA allowing all kind of abuse against HINDUS but refusing to publish anything anti-Muslim. The ISLAMIC FANATICS will never badmouth moderate/secular Muslims as they present a sugarcoated and sanitized islam to kuffar and keep them in false security and unprepared while the fanatic muslims hit them where it hurts- 9/11, 26/11 etc etc. Basically the moderate/secular muslims hold down the feet of the kuffar while real muslims cut their throats
questions raised by karkare wife
In which category, u will place questions raised by Karkare wife.
Karkare's wife raises questions about his death in 26/11 attacks
http://sify.com/news/Karkare-39-s-wife-raises-questions-about-his-death-...
I know I won’t get the answers: Kavita Karkare
http://www.hindu.com/2009/01/14/stories/2009011456181200.htm
Mumbai hero's wife seeks inquiry
http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/south_asia/8366009.stm
My husband was fighting evil: Kavita Karkare
http://ibnlive.in.com/news/my-husband-was-fighting-evil-kavita-karkare/8...
I have lost hope of getting justice: Kavita Karkare
http://www.dnaindia.com/mumbai/report_i-have-lost-hope-of-getting-justic...
Who killed Kamte?
http://www.hindustantimes.com/virsanghvi/Who-killed-Kamte/486600/H1-Arti...
These are the same questions raised by Antuley as well.
MUSLIMS "vote bank politics" led to KARKARE's death.
1--- KARKARE died because of the poor quality of BULLET PROOF JACKET he was wearing- had he been wearing a good quality BULLET PROOF he would have been alive today "irrespective" of where he went or who shot him.
2--- Politicians and Senior Police officials would have taken CRORES as "kick back" while buying substandard BULLET PROOF.
3--- Will anybody say that "corruption" led to KARKARE's death??? Who will answer KAVITHA KARKARE????
The "vote bank" politics of MUSLIMS who vote to keep out BJP from power is equally responsible for the "death of KARKARE"!!!! Confident that MUSLIMS will never allow BJP/SHIV SENA to power, the ruling parties indulge in "whole sale" corruption. The bane of INDIA is "vote bank politics" of MUSLIMS!!!
Jaswnt Singh personally
Jaswnt Singh personally escorted Pakistani to Kandhar during whose Rule?No marks for correct answer.Shall I ask more questions?
and which bastards hijacked
and which bastards hijacked the plane? Why do u forget it? No marks for correct answer.Shall I ask more questions?
Eveyday sun rises from the
Eveyday sun rises from the east and sets in the west.Earth is one of the several satelites of the solar system.Moon is the satelite of earth.These are eternal truths one may deny or not these are the facts.One cant close his eyes and claim that there are no Crusaders,no Hindu terrorists like Bajpai,Hitler didnot exist,babri masjid is not deomlished,partition never happened,and claim that how one reacts is the not the reaction.
If all muslims become true muslims instead of,moderates, apologists,secularists,lefitsts,media favourites,and shiya taqqiya followers then RSS,Zionists,Crusaders,etc will cease to exist.GIVE THANKS TO ALL THESE UNTRUE MUSLIMS AND BOW DOWN!!!!
Is that what is happening???
Sun raising / setting/ moon etc are all natural phenomena which existed even before MUHAMMAD or ISLAM was born. -"RSS, Zionists, Crusaders,etc will cease to exist"- Is that what is happening in AFPAK, SOMALIA, IRAQ, Yemen, SUDAN etc etc etc.
NAQQAAD- see the comment- "shiya taqqiya", now you know where the word has originated.
Batala- More than 250 innocent people were killed by terrorist during 26/11. Since innocent people are anyway being killed a FEW MORE "innocent death"- if that is what you claim BATALA was- while trying to prevent terrorist attack is acceptable.
Would be the last man to support Antule, or the concocted Kharkare theory rightly rejected by all right-thinking people. All that has been stated is that "should Antule wanted a CBI inquiry he could have sought it from PM rather than go public with the TAQQIYA".
Sun,moon etc are
Sun,moon etc are muslims(meaning obedient to Allah(swt),whats nature?nothing but following the laws set by the their creator).Islam is there since the day universe was created,Prophet(saas)was last and final messenger of Islam,Adam(pbuh)was the first messenger of Islam.Now you know the origin of yourself!
Indian muslims are sunnis,no sunni ever indulge in Taqiyya.
Human beings unlike sun and moon are supposed to follow Islam willingly,they have been given freedm of choice to obey or disobey unlike all other creation.
Come forward and dont hide...
Anonymous,
If you have the courage of conviction, why are you not getting yourself verified as a non-Muslim and commenting thereafter?
Mere allegations, without any proof except another shameless comment by a coward is not going to cowdown Muslims. Did you ever tried to verify the various western media you tend to turn for prayers?
Do write on your own Hindu media, the exclusive domain you maintain for serving your bosses of the west. India is going to dogs for your headless efforts of trying to open a front to safeguard your godfathers of west, but for how long. The real India will come hard on you and you'll not have any place to hide. Your masters will not recongnise you and your disservice to India. Better you emigrate to be third class citizens of those land you accept as god.
There is no import required in Islam like the 'secularism' etc as it is the only humane system trying to establish itself. The terrorists you are trying to Islamise are your own creation and you have made sure the mutual destruction. Desist calling these satans Muslim or Islamic. Ask your greatest god the USA as what it was doing when Headley was planning 26/11 or do you deny he did it to save your greater god from getting exposed??
NAQQAAD- comment can be substantiated
M Naqqaad must learn to "agree to disagree". The concept of "off with the head of those who disagree" breeds violence. Learn to say "I DISAGREE WITH YOU BUT I FULLY ACKNOWLEDGE YOUR RIGHT TO HAVE A VIEW WHICH IS AT VARIATION WITH ME". Insistence that OWN views are alone right and all others are wrong is inherent in ISLAM and that precisely is the reason for most violence in the world. Learn to accept "differing opinions" at least when you live in a democracy like India or migrate to Islamic Countries.
NAQQAAD- substantiation of comment
M Naqqaad must learn to "agree to disagree". The concept of "off with the head of those who disagree" breeds violence. Learn to say "I DISAGREE WITH YOU BUT I FULLY ACKNOWLEDGE YOUR RIGHT TO HAVE A VIEW WHICH IS AT VARIATION WITH ME". Unfortunately, ISLAM does not inculcate such qualities in it's followers. The comments are substantiated as under:-
1-- In USA, MAJOR NIDAL MALIK HASAN did the unthinkable- an officer who is to lead his men instead shot them- shouting ALLAHU AKBAR. Prompt was OBAMA in stating that it is NOT Islamic Terrorism, even before investigation commenced.
2-- 26/11 and Mr Anthulay, a cabinet minister who could have convinced the PM to conduct a CBI inquiry opted to go public with wild allegation- which he has failed to substantiate. That is TAQIYYA for you.
Batala House Encounter- again TAQIYYA by intelligentsia of JAMIA Millia .
In TCN itself, RSS/ BJP/ VHP/ JEWS/ BRAHMINS are permanently blamed for all the problems Muslims are facing in India.
DOES IT NOT SUBSTANTIATE THE POST.
Reason is for reasonable
@ Anonymous,
Now you are calling for substantiation!! I am not amused. The reasons and substantiations for the logical mind and I find you have none.
You are a typical example of 'munafiq' which means hypocrate and that is the reason you go all around the globe in trying maligning Islam. Let me know where from you got this word 'taqiyya'? The demand by the minister for the inquiry has been summarily dismissed by the media and society and you again demand he should have asked for one!! You are proving to be a super 'Zionist' when you call the Batla House killing as encounter. You always keep in mind that I have worked for an intelligence agency of the country and the way the current people of my erstwhile fraternity are working is worrysome. If a Headly is recorded planning attack on Bombay and allowed to execute, why not they are asking the govt to stop hobnobbing with the USA which has nothing more than its business of being developed. The relations USA has with Saudi Arabia, China, Turkey, Japan and Israel shows it has no principles but national interest. India being in the vicinity of the people who are feeling the heat of USA actions, should be neutral so that there are no reasons of worries we have now.
Being logical on web will not cut any ice. Nobody would ask us to lower our guard militarily for this. Is this logical thing entering your brain? Yes. So nice. No. Dont ask for substantiation in future.
Allah Knows Best
"To tell a truth in front of a tyrant ruler is the biggest crusade in the sight of Lord. " The writer for reasons unknown to me has mentioned crusade instead of Jihad. Whether he is afraid or does not likes the word Jihad is something Allah Knows Best.
Why at all be surprised?
One need not be surprised for blacking out the news on Karkare book. Most of the so called mainstream, professional and unbiased media in India or for that matter most of the world is on the pay-roll of vested interest. The onus lies on the real media like TCN, the non-commercial voices, to inform people.
Post new comment