Fall of Hyderabad: 17th September a black day in human history




By Kaneez Fathima,

17th September is a black day in the Human history. In the year 1948, this was the day when the Indian Union attacked and occupied the Hyderabad State through Military action which is called as ‘Police Action’ and originally it was named as “Operation Polo”. Lakhs of Muslims were killed in this military attack, women were dishonored. The cities, towns and villages were completely destroyed. Lakhs of Muslims were made homeless. Masjids and Dargahs were dismantled.

Until 17th September 1948, Hyderabad was an independent country popularly named as princely state with Nizam VII, Mir Osman Ali Khan as its ruler. Hyderabad was never under the British rule. Hyderabad was as large as the present country France. It had its own currency, railways, postal department, Judiciary, military etc. In fact, there were 544 princely states then spread all over the area which is presently known as India. Hyderabad was one among them. All these princely states were occupied and merged by the Indian Union after it got independence from the Britishers. But as Hyderabad was one of the largest princely states, the Indian government that was formed after the Britishers left, it wanted Hyderabad to merge into Indian union, because Hyderabad State was in between the North and South regions, therefore, if Indian Union wanted to rule over the Southern region then it was not possible so they wanted to occupy the Hyderabad state, so that they can include the whole North and South regions and rule over it. However, the VII Nizam did not agree to the proposal of Indian government and wanted some time to think about it as the Britishers had given him three choices, one is to merge into Indian Union, two is to remain independent and the third is to merge into newly formed Pakistan.



Let us examine ‘Liberation’ in what sense and from whom? In the year 1948, on the pretext of suppressing communist movement that was spread only in four districts of Hyderabad State, the Indian union attacked the Hyderabad state to overthrow the Nizam rule which was considered as Muslim rule. Though the police action was to occupy Hyderabad state but actually in the name of police action, Muslims were killed in large numbers. It was estimated officially by the Sundarlal Committee appointed by the government of India that One Lakh Muslims were killed by the Indian army and unofficial estimation is more than two lakh Muslims were killed. The Arya Samaj and other Hindu fundamentalist organizations along with Indian military were involved in the killing of Muslims. 17th September is not the liberation day but day of genocide, the implications of which can be felt even today.

The Nizam of Hyderabad State never even thought of this type of massacre, because he always considered Hindus and Muslims as his two eyes. The way the people of Hyderabad were targeted due to the Nizam of Hyderabad, Mir Osman Ali Khan’s innocence and lack of future understanding, he underwent shock due to that. All his dreams went scattered, his tongue went soar, because this richest man of the world would never have dreamt that his home would be destroyed so brutally in front of his eyes and he was unable to do anything.



The Indian Union’s aim was not just to exterminate the Nizam’s government, but also to erase the culture, language, history and literature of Hyderabad. So, the Nizam’s government was eliminated by one attack, but the culture, language, history and literature that has strong roots, could not be erased even after the military action of 17th September. But it has been continuously under attack. The recent uprising Telangana movement is born/emerged from the remaining of culture, heritage and language of Hyderabad, which is called Hyderabadi tahzeeb. Because of this we have given the slogan Hyderabad is Telangana and Telangana is Hyderabad.

It is time now to think as to who is benefiting by giving the slogans of ‘Liberation Day’ and who wants the state government to declare this day officially as liberation day. In the year 1948, as the Congress gave the reasons of suppressing the communist movement and occupied the Hyderabad state to overthrow the Nizam’s rule, in the present times, BJP is using the same strategy and supporting the Telangana movement and propagating that the Muslim rule will come back. One should also think as to why the BJP and TRS have been celebrating this particular day? These two parties are working on same ideological line and majoritarian ideology of these parties will make the people to stand against Muslims. The BJP is making communal statements and instigating common people against Muslims and bringing differences among the communities. So, the SCs, STs and BCs are thinking on the lines of BJP. On the one hand TRS praises Nizam for providing infrastructure and on the other hand it is depicting him as enemy of the people. This dual stand will benefit them both in getting more votes in forthcoming elections. More than this both the parties want to hide the real history of Hyderabad. History is not a monolithic one, it must be read in multiple ways and bring out the facts to construct the understanding.



This day has been celebrated by the BJP and Congress as liberation day. TDP celebrated it as a merger day and the TRS and left parties have celebrated it as betrayal day and the Muslim, SC, ST, and Bahujan organizations have named it as Invasion day. So, there is no clear understanding among the political parties as to what they should call the day 17th September as.

We can understand with the opinion of various political parties that they are not sincere towards the separate Telangana movement and are playing vote bank politics to increase their political employment.

We Telanganites are still under the suppression of the Seemandhras, so we haven’t got the liberation and freedom yet. Though India has got independence in the year 1947, Hyderabad was already independent. But after the merger, the Andhra occupied the Telangana region, diverted all the natural resources to their region and now they have occupied the Waqf lands and are ruling over us. Therefore, people of Telangana are still under the suppression of the Seemandhras. Therefore, in real sense we haven’t got freedom yet. Unless and until Telangana is formed as a separate state, we cannot say that we are free and liberated.

There was no Telangana movement at the time when the Indian Union attacked the Hyderabad State. There was only communist movement that too spread over a small part of the Hyderabad state, say in four districts. Therefore, 17th September cannot be considered as Liberation day as it had no connection with Telangana freedom. It is a black day in human history as lakhs of Muslims were massacred. Telangana people who know about the history of Hyderabad very clearly also know that 17th September is neither a liberation day, nor betrayal day but in fact it is a black day in human history.

(The author is attached with Muslim Forum for Telangana)

Comments

which world does the author live in

It is clear and unfortunate that the author, using this website, is giving only one sided view of the true history. Let me see how many true or false Indians will condemn this article.

Hyderabad

Is the author an Indian or a Pakistani? Such fictitious lies make people lose all respect for twocircles.net itself.

very sorry to read such an

very sorry to read such an unfortunate article... with due respect to your wisdom Ma'm, I suggest you re-read the history (again its debatable which document is genuine if the historians themselves are biased; but lets give benefit of doubt) by walking upto the Library in Afzalganj... by reading an opinion of a Sree in a blog or a comment by a Khan in electronic media or by a tweet or some other opinionated 'expert' interview in TV/paper we will never understand the facts nor will we be in a better position to join a meaningful debate.

Having said all that, let me make one direct comment; its Nizam's choice not to merge with Indian Union on 15/8/1947 and his choice to contemplate on remaining independent Vs joining Pak... fair enough; similarly, it was people's choice to join hands with Indian Union, i.e., choose democracy; and I also want to clarify that just because this is perceived as one community's website, it does not mean that one has to write/publish articles to appease that community; by doing so one is doing injustice to them and dare I say ridiculing their intelligence.

PS: You & I are able to still have a reasonable dialogue over this forum because of the wonderful democratic freedom we enjoy; where multiple opinions/ideas/views are allowed their space... and purely from my personal perspective (lest I generalise and be perceived as appeasing my community etc) I prefer to have this freedom to disagree/debate with someone rather than pay a monarch to be allowed to plough my own land and lose my family to oppresive rulers. and I am saying from the experience of my own grand father not by mere speculation.

Jai Telangana!
Jai Bharat!

WHAT WAS RIGT FOR HYDERABADI HINDUS WAS CONSIDERED BAD FOR KASHM

YOU SAY THAT IT WAS 'THE PEOPLE'S CHOICE TO JOIN THE INDIAN UNION AND WHAT THE MASSES DESIRED WAS FULFILLED BY THE INDIAN GOVERNMENT. IF THAT BE SO, WHY DID IT NOT AND WHY DOES IT NOT FULFILL THE WISHES OF THE KASHMIRIS TO BE FREE FROM THE CLUTCHES OF THE MAJORITY COMMUNITY DOMINATED GOVERNMENT OF INDIA AND BE INDEPENDENT? IF HINDUS DEMAND A THING, THE G.O.I CONSIDERS IT GOOD,WHEREAS IF MUSLIMS DESIRE THE SAME THING, IT IS CONSIDERED BAD BY IT. THIS SORT OF JUSTICE IS LOPSIDED AND SO UNJUST
S.M.PASHA

Hyderabad

Kashmir was to be given the choice after Pakistan Army was withdrawn from Kashmir. Has that happened yet?

Even Pakistan laid a

Even Pakistan laid a condition that it will withdraw its armed forces from POK if India removes its army from the region so that a plebiscite can take place which was not accepted by our government.

READ MY BOOKLET ON THE RAPE OF NIZAM'S HYDERABADS

PLEASE READ MY BOOKLET ENTITLED " THE RAPE OF NIZAM'S HYDERABAD" IT IS ON THE VERY SAME TOPIC. IT WILL OPEN YOUR EYES. ASK AND THOU SHALT BE GIVEN A COPY FREE OF COST.. MAY ALLAH BLESS THE MUSLIM COMMUNITY WITH MANY SUCH KANEEZES OF FATHIMA (R)
S.M.PASHA
"Baithul Aman" N-51/O-22, BARRACKS ROAD, PERIAMET, CHENNAI 600003

History repeats itself many

History repeats itself many times. The Muslim named Kingdoms of today ( read middle east ) are the Nizam states of yesterday.

Article with no sense

I just find this article to be a provocative article with little of actual facts attached.

IF that is the case, then

IF that is the case, then something to worry about, and were been ditched and were living in fool paradise. Hyderabadi aur Lucknow ko unhiki sharafat aur tehzeeb maar gai.. Shame.
faruqi - lucknow-basi

Nothing will change

Muslims killings was never condemned nor will be. First British adapted divide n rule policy now this majority has adapted. Majority forgot what British did in India but they can never forget anything did by a Muslim. Biased Nature, even today muslims r killed all over the world.

Interesting information, it

Interesting information, it would be more informative if the author could give more information about the history in question.
@which world does the author live in, should rather ask "how many true or false Telanganites / the then Hyderabadis" will condemn this article.

very bad article

TwoCirlces,Please remove this secessionist article.This will give fodder to Hindutva forces to accuse muslims of being unpatriotic.

Great and informative artices

Great and informative artices shows the dirty design of earlier indian politicians...against Muslims..

A Shocking Article

I have to study a lot to comment on this article. Anyhow it is a Shocking Article.

17th SEPT. MUST BE OBSERVED AS YOUMUL ASWADH

17th SEPTEMBER MUST BE OBSERVED AS AN 'YOUMUL ASWADH" AND ON THAT DAY RECALL HOW CRUELLY AND UNJUSTLY THE THEN GOVT. OF INDIA SWALLOWED THE SALTHANATH OF A MUSLIM PRINCELY STATE
S.M.PASHA

Is this what we all want to

Is this what we all want to do? Should we all open up past wounds and start creating communal disharmony and undermine Indian integrity? What has happened has happened. We are one country now. Should Hindus also list out all the atrocities committed by the muslims in India during the time of the Muslim conquest of the Indian subcontinent and should hence strive to drive away all muslims from the country?

Lies

The author is giving only one sides view of history which is dangerous for for the foundation of indian union. She must alos highlight the atrcociteis commited by NIzam ' s razakars.

Misleadind article

Dear Sir,
why yu are trying to mislead the people by giving fake details. Nizam's people have killed scores of hindus and even ban "Satyarh prakash". This was the reason that at that time Arya Samaj took the arms after peacefull agitation and start the agitation to end the devil's rule

"Lakhs of Muslims were killed

"Lakhs of Muslims were killed in this military attack." - can you provide independent proof or documentation behind this claim? If not, please refrain from making such sensationalist and divisive claims.

SUNDERLAL REPORT - IS THE REPLY.

Dear Ms. Garga Chatterjee : Yes ! There is a report titled : "Sunderlal Report" ! Please read it. Members of the Commission : Sri. Sunderlal (A Congressman from Allahabad UP), Kazi Abdul Kayyum (Hyderabad AP) and Sri. Srinivas Lahoti (Communist Party - Hyderabad AP).

I hope you have the time - intellectual honesty and integrity - and scholarly depth - to go thru the whole report and arrive at your own conclusions dis-passionately. Thanks.

Please post a link to the

Please post a link to the sunderlal report here and mention the page where it is found after investigation that lakhs of muslims were killed in hyderabad.

Hyderabad post 'policte action' carnage

Here is the link: http://www.frontlineonnet.com/fl1805/18051140.htm
In the same issue of Front Line, there is an article by AG Noorani. Gujarat & Delhi pale out before the number of deaths reported in these pages. I have personal knowledge of a reported execution of over a hundred 'razakars' after lining them up.

Hyderabad

It's wrong to assume that Hyderabad was a sovereign country. All princely states of India had lost their international personality under the Royal Titles Act, 1867, and became the dependencies of the Crown.
It was wrong on the part of Nizam to opt for independence since the state was situated within the Indian Union with the majority of inhabitants being Hindu.
It was only after the military action that the Nizam realized his folly and received Sardar Patel with folded hands.
Who is guilty for the death and destruction in 1948 the gullible people of Hyderabad or the self-conceited feudals surrounding the Nizam?

Hyderabad

The writer should read the history of the Indian states. Their rulers were the vassals of the Lord Paramount. It was wrong on the part of Nizam to opt for independence when the state was situated within the Indian Union and the majority of population was Hindu. Please read K.M. Munshi's "End of an Era" for more light.

The author proves my point.

The writer of this article proves my point about Indian muslims being anti-national and basically Pakistanis at heart. They will love India only if India becomes an Islamic state. They have nothing but contempt for India's hindu traditions. They want Islamic rule back in India. For any hindu reading, we must realise these people are our eternal enemies, and treat them the same way they treat us. With contempt and hatred.

Please read K.M. Munshis book

Please read K.M. Munshis book "End of an Era" to get enlightened about the integration of Hyderabad.

True Article but shortly mentioned

Twocircles have given the correct article which show the true history of Hyderabad State under Nizam's Rule. As i am hyderabadi & my ancestors (Great Grand Father) was the Subedaar(Like CM) of Mahboobnagar district in the past.I am having complete history as it is available in Bangladesh/Pakistan that how indian union invaded/conquered/destabilized hyderabad under leadership of sardar vallabh bhai patel. See i am an indian & im proud to be democratic indian muslim and we indian muslims are more patriotic than hindu brothers as we fought equally for freedom of india and our muslim freedom fighters like Ashfaqullah khan, maualana azad,mohammed ali jinnah etc.... The Hsitory can be changed/erased which is in your hand but it cannot be changed/erased which is in other countries hand, if anyone wants a dialogue with me can sent me an email on

Some room for Truth

When one wants "Free Speech", one has to concede the same right to others, such as the author of present post. She is proposing an alternate narrative of what happened during the *Police Action* in the then Hyderabad state. If she wants to be taken seriously, then she should have shown at least some respect for truth. She subverts her own agenda in the beginning paragraph.

"*Lakhs of Muslims were killed in this military attack*, women were dishonored. *The cities, towns and villages were completely destroyed*. *Lakhs of Muslims were made homeless*. *Masjids and Dargahs were dismantled*".

Would she care to substantiate her outlandish claims (between two **)? In publishing such articles twocircles.net is showing blatant disregard to its own credibility. I used to hold it as a source of reliable information though I confess I don't visit it often.

I hope owners issue an explanation.

Sister Kaneez Fathima!

Dear Editor,
TCN has done it once again. I really feel sad for being a regular reader of TCN for the past couple of years. I now feel that people like me shall not visit this portal which is dedicated to pleasing the Muslim community and to widen the gap between the two major communities of the country without concerning about the consequences there off.
Dear Editor I would once again like to advise you to refrain from publishing these kinds of imaginary articles which are far from reality and are only meant at creating a rift in the mindset of the Muslim youth so as to prepare them to stand against their own brothers from other communities in their nation.
This article trying to glorify the villains like the Razakar leader who had tortured lakhs of non muslims in those heinous days and is trying to vilify the real heroes and the sufferers of those days. I don't know what was the intension of sister Kaneez Fathima behind writing such an article of lies and pure lies but I hope she perhaps belongs to the family of one such upper section which had enjoyed their proximity to the throne of Nizam and might have been failing to come into terms with the common life style which she might have been subjected as a result of the accession of Nizam's Hyderabad.

I know for a fact that it is

I know for a fact that it is true that the Muslims were mascarred in the Police action not by terrorists but our own Indian army. I have always wondered how anyone could possibly some one like vallabhai Patel. Come to think of it, even now in recent times, it is another Gujrati who was behind the Gujrat pogram. But ofcourse we cant colour all gujrat people in the same colour. MK gandhi was one too.
Let's face it, even history is biased. If people are today contradicting the police action and praising instead of acknowledging the killing of innocents, then it is a pity cause they are misled by history in coloured in communalism.

And you missed the point of

And you missed the point of it all. MKG is the root of all evil that exist in india. Dont be cheated by him roaming nanga chanting rama.

Let us not play a game

Dear Readers
Putting the viewes are everybodies right,lets put our efferts to make our surroundings free from evel deeds and builed united India to achive our goals in the world market instead of pulling each other legs,Be dessisive in investments and grouing your generation with green cocept save envornament reduce pollution
It is good to no histry from the liberaries with deffrents authores of Thoughts not to take revenge but to create communal hormony
Mohammed Toufeeque

PIYE HUQQE KAA DAM - BAHADUR YUNG

Piye Huqqe Kaa Damm - Bahadur Jung
Gaye Mulk-e-Adamm - Bahaadur Jung
16 Zillon ke Khamb (Khamba) - Bahadur Jung

(A folk song circa 1948).

Princely State Hyderabad-Dn died the day its most popular leader Bahadur Yar Jung was assasinated (poisoned) 28 June 1944. After that., Sir. Mirza Ismail and Nawab Saheb Chattari tried to SAVE Hyderabad from a horrible-end., and even Lord. Mountbatten hinted at it VERY CLEARLY in his letter to Sir. Walter Monckton (of Brenchley). A horrible END was very clear and very visible - and this man-made disaster COULD have been avoided with TIMELY action.

The Nizam of Hyderabad under the influence of drugs and courtiers vaccilated ! And played both sides. Thru Ali Yavar Jung, he sent a message to Delhi : "Kill all muslims of Hyderabad State IF you so wish, but save me and my King Kothi". Pt. Jawaharlal Nehru addressing a meeting in Ganjoti Paigah - Latur, Osmanabad said (that was the nearest he came to utter the truth) : "Aap logon ne kyoun hinsaa kee - Nizam ne khud Bharatiya Sena ko bulaaya thaa".

YES : Lakhs of Muslims were massacred ! By the invading Indian Army and by the Local Hindus. People "settled" their scores with neighbours ! Hindus started identifying Hindu homes ! 20% of the Male Population of Hyderabad-State was dead. Uneducated people consider only the city of Hyderabad when they talk about the Hyderabad Invasion circa 1948. Hyderabad State was the Capital of Hyderabad-Deccan state., which was the size of France and Belgium., and muslims were spread across the State ! Its not just Hyd-City., it was the Muslims scattered across the Hyd-STATE/Dominion., that got killed. Thousands (if not lakhs) of women were raped. The old women were killed - the young ones raped and killed (thereafter). Women jumped into the well to save their honor. Husbands killed their wives., fathers killed their daughters., brothers killed their sisters., before their honour was flouted !

It is a very gruesome tale. After the Punjab Front 1947., it was Hyderabad Invasion Sept 1948.

Who is to be blamed ? Well : TO A MAJOR EXTENT : The VII Nizam of Hyderabad - for his double-dealing (double-crossing) - vaccilating - and living in a fanciful world due to the INFLUENCE OF DRUG-ADDICTION.

Hyd-Dn would have gone to India in any case - but HAD Bahadur Yar Jung been alive - the end would not have been this tragic. Bahadur Yar Jung had a vision and was a very charming conversationist. He was graceful. A meeting between BYJ and Sardar Vallabhai Patel would have led to a different ending (unlike the Rizvi-Patel meeting) ! BYJ would have settled for 20% Reservation for Muslims in academia and jobs for 15% Muslim-population of Hyd-Dn. Nehru would have approved., and even Vallabhai Patel., would have consented !

Read the last para of Mountbatten's letter to the Nizam before leaving ! The Nizam should have negotiated while Mountbatten was still the GG. Mountbatten had great respect for Monckton - and Monckton did the best any Lawyer could ! But under the influence of DRUGS and UNEDUCATED people, the Nizam snubbed him. Once that GOLDEN OFFER was snubbed., it was a slide. The Nizam was NOT interested in saving any Muslim. He was worrying for his skin and his family ! It had come to that. And he expressed no remorse for lakhs of muslims killed (due to his indecision and inaction). He lived for 19 yrs after Police Action., and produced a dozen kids., AFTER Police Action !

Such a stupid, cheap, mean-spirited, uneducated drug-addict was he. A Sultan-Ul-Uloom who did not know how to read/write any language perfectly... though he wrote verse in Urdu and Persian., his knowledge of English was extremely meagre, not to use stronger language ! No Kid (Son/Daughter) from the House of Sultan-ul-Uloom could get out of school (Matriculation) ! None knew how to read the Koran perfectly. [Mukarram Jah - the grandson - did study at Sandhurst - and that is because Princess Durreshehwar - a GREAT LADY - took him away from the evil influence of the Hyderabadi Mahoul).

Dirty Jokes (Like "Dirty Picture") - Filthy Talk with Hosh Bilgrami - Drugs and Fancy : The Nizam was crazy ("Khatar-naak qism kaa paagal" to quote Josh Malihabadi), medically ! Unfit for the position he was in.

who wrote this stupid

who wrote this stupid article....arey sala....who destroyed our culture,who made urdu as official language though 90% are hindus,who banned hindu festivals....none other than stupid,uneducated,drug and sex addict,the nizam.....who given right to rule india land...india is a land of hindus......jai shri ram,jai hind

1948 india karbala

1948 17 - 20 sept. ye din hum kabhi nahi bhula sakenge , is din hamareliye qyamat guzri thi, hamari zamin 200 acre , daualat , izzat , jaan , maal , sab kuch loot liya gaya ,

Ma'm Kanees Fathima is correct

Dear All,
Ma'm Kanees is correct cause i heard from my grand father his own words a lacks of muslims killed by hindus in the name of police action.

NIZAM was a selfish ruler

NIZAM was a STOOGE of the BRITISH- 1-- he supported British against TIPU from 1780-1799 and gave 36000 soldiers in the attack on TIPU at in Mysore in which TIPU was killed.----------- 2--- NIZAM supported BRITISH in the 1857 too. BRITISH may have been thrown out then itself had it not been for NIZAMs support. --- 3-- NIZAM gave Rs 25 Crore to Pakistan in 1948 when Pakistan was killing Indian soldiers in Kashmir. --- 4--- There was no provision in "the Indian Independence Act" for any Princly State to remain independent- choice was only between Indian & Pak.--5-- Had "land locked HYDERBAD" with India on all sides, become part of PAK, it would have become a "perpetual" source ISLAMIC TERRORISM for India. --6-- Hindus in large numbers were being killed by NIZAMS ARMY & RAZAKARS. So India had to use Army. (when Muslims were being killed in BOZNIA by SERBS all Muslims demanded UN to save Boznian Muslims). Since it was the MUSLIM NIZAM ARMY which opposed Indian Army more Muslims could have been killed. ---7--- HYDERABAD State had only about 10-20% Muslims with the MAJORITY being Hindus but Hindus were discriminated and 80% of NIZAMs Army, Employees & Landlords were MUSLIMS. ---8--- DEMOCRACY is all about "will of the MAJORITY"- and HINDUS are MAJORITY in INDIA. So the will of HINDUS will prevail in a "DEMOCRATIC INDIA". All Unhappy INDIANS in DEMOCRATIC INDIA can migrate to any part of the world as they like.

COLLATERAL - THE HOSTAGE THEORY

First and foremost., Jinnah never wanted partition. It was only his barganing ploy ! He wanted the best deal for indian muslims.

Who first talked about partition ?

Vinayak Damodar Savarkar !

It was Savarkar's desire.............................

Thie article

proves that Indian Muslims have and will never beleive in concept of India.

Just edit the title Madame

Would request the Author to edit the title at the end ...

This article makes a better reading as "Fall of Hyderabad: 17th September a black day in Islamic history", goes without saying a great day for Bharath.

this is a classic case of those who stick rigidly by one book, for them history does not exist before their faith began, faith is larger than Nation. They do not care a damn to Bharth the only continuous civilization for the past 10 to 12 thousand years.

I can only say, pity you Madame, it is evident that poeple of you ilk are still living in gloomy days with future going to me gloomier as no Nizam will emerge and make Hyderabad free from Bharath as Bhagyanagar was part of Bharath even 2000 years back when you know .... :)

be cool

dont suspect our natonalism, what th editor says was just an event happened
we love our country and we are ready to sacrifice our motherland
and pls dont critize the editor of article

hisotry cannot be repeat so dont make an issue

you forget how muslims general and majors sacrifice for our motherland and fought aganisnt enemies pakistan and china

beleive me if time come i will be th first to sacrifice for our nationa

definately why not this ismy country my people my brothers my sisters we are deeply culturally, socially bonded each other so dont sustpect our natonalism

be cool

dont suspect our natonalism, what th editor says was just an event happened
we love our country and we are ready to sacrifice our motherland
and pls dont critize the editor of article

hisotry cannot be repeat so dont make an issue

you forget how muslims general and majors sacrifice for our motherland and fought aganisnt enemies pakistan and china

beleive me if time come i will be th first to sacrifice for our nationa

definately why not this ismy country my people my brothers my sisters we are deeply culturally, socially bonded each other so dont sustpect our natonalism

Muslims are Nationalist?

You are right Sajid. Muslim community would be the first community to sacrifice for their Mother Land i.e. PAKISTHAN.

your editorial

dear anees
now past is past i dont see any importance to the previous war and love stories
but now we will have to move side by side as one nation and some of the writers spoke harshly against you its not fair because india is a democratic country every one has right speak pls writers, dont show enemity towards our own fellow citizen

i know she speaks not by hatred but sympathy to people wo lost their lives and was really a massacre lets forget and unit together, muslims are really not enemy to india or hindus
and i beleive every indian muslims should love india as our motherland

dont you read how our own indian belong to majority community so coruppted and they do not care our country then where is their nationalism. don not underestimate the sacrifices made by muslims for independent india even on frontiers warriors like abdul hameed and shawnawz khan they barvely fought against our enemies so dont go far beyond and unnessarsily critize kaneez

lets forget everything and work for th development of india the great

i love my country i like my people and even ready to sacrifice for my nation
its my motherland dont spread hatred among our people pls stop writers

kaneez she narrated an old event so do not take to hearts it was happened so you cannot deny you can say brother kills brother so now everything is disappeared now should respect each and love and sacrifice for our motherland

go hand in hand and no foreign power would ever dare to lok at you

dont be narrow minded many obstacles on our way so be united and wait to sacrifices for the nation

your editorial

dear anees
now past is past i dont see any importance to the previous war and love stories
but now we will have to move side by side as one nation and some of the writers spoke harshly against you its not fair because india is a democratic country every one has right speak pls writers, dont show enemity towards our own fellow citizen

i know she speaks not by hatred but sympathy to people wo lost their lives and was really a massacre lets forget and unit together, muslims are really not enemy to india or hindus
and i beleive every indian muslims should love india as our motherland

dont you read how our own indian belong to majority community so coruppted and they do not care our country then where is their nationalism. don not underestimate the sacrifices made by muslims for independent india even on frontiers warriors like abdul hameed and shawnawz khan they barvely fought against our enemies so dont go far beyond and unnessarsily critize kaneez

lets forget everything and work for th development of india the great

i love my country i like my people and even ready to sacrifice for my nation
its my motherland dont spread hatred among our people pls stop writers

kaneez she narrated an old event so do not take to hearts it was happened so you cannot deny you can say brother kills brother so now everything is disappeared now should respect each and love and sacrifice for our motherland

go hand in hand and no foreign power would ever dare to lok at you

dont be narrow minded many obstacles on our way so be united and wait to sacrifices for the nation

Pro nizam viws

Pity on u madam.Your informatiom is though very informatic, it protrayed a wrong picture of india.in the history of 1000 years,india never attacked any country.Nizam of Hydrabd was a trator.He siphoned about 20 crores to pakistan and denied indian right to this princely state.Indian army did right thing .It was not a black day but a day of victory to india.

long live india.

Operation Polo

AlhamdoLillah,I am The Grandson of the Razakar Leader Syed Mohammed Qasim Razvi, who indeed was a nightmare for the extremist hindus of the era.

The were than as extremist as they are scattered today all over India.

Needless to give you names of those extremist hindu all time fractions.

Siddique-e-Aazam,Mujaahid-e-Deccan Syed Mohammed Qasim Razvi was the person who leashed these trigger happy extremist hindus than and tried to do what might have been best in the interest of all.

Speaking of which, it had always been a "Traitor" within and in this case it was The Nizam's Army General Ahmed El-Edroos.

I do have my very serious reservation regarding the partition, which for one i call "Division" of a great country called India.

Having said that, i do disagree also with the idea of calling two wrongs a right.

Indian government did commit a blunder in the case of Deccan Hyderabad and is doing so in Kashmir as well.

It will only add up to hatred.

We Reap What We Sow.....So Shall You.

Humble Regards,

Peace To All.

Dear Ammar...

I guess you are the son of Jus. Majida Rizvi, Mr. Kasim Rizvi's daughter ? Anyway, with due respect, Mr. Kasim Rizvi overplayed his hand. Bahadur Yar Jung would have handled Patel differently, and results would have been different.

Hyderabad went to dogs the day Sir. Mirza Ismail left Hyderabad. Many names come to mind. Mir Laiq Ali, Aidroos, Hosh Bilgrami, KM Munshi, Ramanand Teerath, PV Narasimha Rao, etc. Anyone who said the truth was labelled a "Traitor". Hyderabad-Dn was lost because of foolishness. Nizam, a drug addict changed the draft many a time. The best draft was the one that came before Mountbatten left. That was THE best draft. But Nizam refused under pressure from Rizvi & Laiq Ali. They under-estimated Patel's resolve. Laiq Ali open bluffed (100 planes ready in Arabia to attack in case...) and took the innocent muslims of Hyd-Dn for a ride. Their intent may have been honourable, but they lacked wisdom. Sorry to say... Due to ZIDD, they lost the country to the British first, then to the Congress. Even after 1947 (Punjab/Bengal), they did not wake up in Hyd. Hyd was living in delusion. Uncaring for what was happening around. In its own pink fanciful dream of "Aal Izz Well". Nizam did NOT listen to Sir Mirza Ismail and Nawab Chattari. They left. Hyderabadis took over - gave inflamatory speeches - Kasim Rizvi was a rabble-rouser - lakhs of people died as a response to those speeches.

Even Bahadur Yar Jung's Pan-Islamic vision was FLAWED. Sorry, but thats the truth. But BYJ still had a political acumen and sense. He would have accepted the Patel/Mountbatten draft after 1947. BYJ-Patel meeting would have led to different result(s) and outcome(s). I think so. Maybe I am wrong... its an academic question now.

peace

Why we look for the past we should think on the future side and not only muslims but also hindus have lost thier lives and property during the period of police action and partitions but accordingly the population of Muslims have came down which means somewhere something wrong is happened let just forget about it and move towards bright future.

Pages