Do you consider Jinnah as a secular person?

Mr. Kulkarni's resegnation clearly shows that Jaswant Singh"s Book was written with the planned strategy of the BJP to blame congress and its secular leadership for the division of the country and project BJP as a centralist party to replace the Congress in the Centre.But fortunatly, the defeat of the BJP in the last elections, had completly changed the situation and the RSS rejected the stretegy and blamed the Policies of soft Hindutva Of Mr. Bajpai as the main cause of the crushing defeat of the BJP.So Mr. Jaswant Singh was expelled from the party and Mr. Kulkarni had to resign at his own.

Mr. Jaswant Singh's only intention was to make Nehru and other secular ledership of the congress responsible for the partition of the country, and project BJP as a centralist party to occupy the centre of power by replacing congress' In this process they also wanted to get rid of the RSS's iron hold on their organisation. The Book was meant for bringing in a change from rigid hindutwa to Soft Hindutwa of Mr Bajpai. But the strategy failed because of the defeat in the elections and RSS rejected the policy of soft hindutwa.

Mr Jaswant Singh may have thought that praising Jinnah will give him muslim support, which is untrue. Jinnah was never a secular person and I think Muslim League has never fought for the independence of India, they have always demanded for a seperate country. A person who was not concerned about the freedom struggle should not be considered a secular person. And what about Gandhi and Patel? Jaswant can consider them racist but this is a false concept. The problem is, we are not proud of the people who have struggled for the country. Jaswant is a sick person and he should be medicated for such statements.

Im a muslim and i can tell you Jinnah was a racist!! He is to blame for so much of the muslim v The World fighting and in India, of which I am a proud citizen, he ruined this great counrty with much help from the British, whom he always sucked up to. He was the devil incarnate and did not even live for a year in his beloved 'pakiland'. the curse of so many holy people is upon his head and that land as long as it stays away from the rest of its holy self.