What should be done with Ranganath Misra Commission report?

The report must be make public for debates. The report has many references that would expose the ill intentions of those who have ruled India. Rather the HINDU and Muslims of India must come together and expose the politcians.
daya sagar dayasagr45@yahoo.com

Tamil Nadu Thowheed Jamath (TNTJ) has planned to organise a massive conference in Chennai on 4th July 2010, Demanding Separate Reservation in Education and Employment of Central Government said S. Sithiqu M. Tech – Secretary – TNJ Students Wing accompanied by M. Sarvath Khan, Assistant Secretary and Executive Member K.M.S. Sadiq Batcha.

Muslims had Reservation in Pre-Independance period, the right was snatched away by the so called secular Government. Even after 60 years of Independence, the status of Muslims is far below than the national Average and other Socio-Religious communities.

To review the status of backward communities, the Central Government has appointed the famous named committee “Mandal Commission”, which has outlined in detail including Muslims community. Subsequent to Mandal Commission, Central Government, has appointed Justice Sachar and Justice Ranganath Misra Commission to study the status of Indian Muslims in Education, Employment and socio-Economic conditions.

Justice Sachar and Justice Ranganath Misra Commissions had rightly outlined the pathetic conditions of Indian Muslims and to overcome the issue, the committee has suggested a number of Measures. One such important measure was to provide a Separate Reservations for Muslims in Education and Employment of Central Government, reference to Provisions of Constitution of India, vide Article 15,16(4) and 46.

Muslim backwardness is a National Problem
The Report has made numerous recommendations for urgent governmental action to redress the problem of Muslim backwardness. This is essential not only in the interest of equity and fair play. It is also in the National Interest because no country can hope to progress if it leaves behind 150 million of its population.

To speed up our Demand and pressure the Central Government to act on the Recommendations, TNTJ has organized Nationwide Campaign to create awareness among Muslims and take the support of Secular People. As a first step, Tamil Nadu Thowheed Jamath (TNTJ) has planned to organise State Level Massive Conference in Chennai on 04th July 2010, in which 15 Lakhs Muslims across the state is expected to take part in this conference and TNTJ will invite all Muslim Political parties across India, to take part in this conference.

TNTJ is in co-ordination with like minded Group, to form a Nationwide Movement to organise Nationwide Muslims Conference, across India and to take the issue Nationwide more aggressively.

Further, Mr. S. Sithiqu M.Tech said that, Muslims demand for Reservation is not based on Religion, based on their Educational, Employment and Socio-Economic Status and the Constitution has provisions to accommodate such demand. Muslims main Agenda and demand in the coming days will be Separate Reservations. It’s high time, the Congress should realise the importance. In the Past Muslims were depending mainly on the Congress alone! But today’s prevailing political scenario, Muslims look forward to align with Even Non-Congress Secular parties!! The congress can’t treat the Muslims just for Vote bank politics alone!!

Rangnath Misra Commission Report will never be implemented simply because it is more important for the Congress Party to appease the 80% Hindus, rather than the 14% Muslims.This is simple political arithmetic.

Non-Muslims get reservations, concessions, privileges because when they vote they demand those things.

But Muslims vote out of fear of communal riots, butchery, demolitions, Gujarat like massacre etc and so after the elections they get back the fear.

When the Muslims ask for reservations not based on religion but based on their economic deprivation, they get commissions, just to please them and the commission reports are absolute eye wash and a huge deception.

Never in the history of 62 years of India, any commission that does any favourable report on Muslim minorities has ever been implemented.

So what is the solution? Political polarisation. Big Muslim Bosses in all the main political parties should tender their resignation, say good-bye and leave their parties and lose their incomes and start a huge political party that can unite the entire Muslim Umma of India, and then THAT will create fear in the minds of the politicians and then we can get at least some of our reasonable demand met.

Otherwise there is no chance

One OTHER solution. Forget about Govt crumbs and start working hard, educate our children, start our own businesses and try to emulate the Jews of the USA and empower ourselves economically, then the politicians will be our mercenaries, after all the entire national system works on bribery in India from peons to Ministers.
But this solution requires tremendous sacrifice and tremendous AMAL JARIAH from the rich Muslims who are mostly tight fisted.

Mr Mishra is the formore cheifjustice of india he had a vast knowledge on community and reservation beside that if you dont belive on any one so dont give a cance to invetigate and produce a repot please take an action assoon as possoble

The Constitution (Scheduled Castes) Order 1950 paragraph 3 defines a Scheduled Caste in terms of religion and not in terms of social educational backwardness. Hence it is an order that goes against the secular principles enshrined in the Constitution. The criterion should be social and educational backwardness. Apart from the Ranganath Misra Commission report another important study was published by the Department of Sociology, University of Delhi, 2008 "Dalits in Christian and Muslim communities: A Status Report on Current Social Scientific Knowledge. Since the last Major judicial pronouncement on Dalit Christian issue (Soosai Vs Union of India) there is a lot more evidence available on the social economical and educational backwardness of Dalit Christians and as per this study "there is no compelling evidence to justify denying SC status to Dalit Muslims and Dalit Christians." Every fair- minded Indian would support the cause of Dalit Muslims and Christians on basis of justice

If India is really secular state, special previleges should not be given to any group based on religion. It is sheer hypocricy for some religious groups to claim religious credentials when they want special previleges and claim freedom from the obligation to obey and behave like the rest of the citizens when they are required to obey the laws of the country.

Afterall, nobody in his senses can claim Muslims remained backward in India due to suppression by Hindus, because the former were ruling the country for about a thousand years until the advent of the British.At the time of the British departure, Muslims extracted their pound of flesh.
if it is true that they they are economically backward now, it is because they prefer to adhere to outdated customs and to a type of education that indoctinates them against the mainstream life of people and to live in their exclusive sectarian religious shells.

There are millions of people poorer than some Muslims.It is they, who are really suppressed by a series of national governments to please the so called religious minorities. Afterall,why should religion be taken as criterion for classifying as minorities, unless it is aimed at creating class conflict and gaining political advantage? The criterion should be economic and physical disabilities if the government is honest. The report should be shelved.

Raganadh Mishra commission report should be publish and actions to be taken without delay

sir
i did not found my name in the list
please help me

There is no need of any further discussion on the situation of muslims in India.Their plight was well depicted by sachar and now mishra suggested the actions to be taken. Debate is required only if the issue is not clear. Is there anybody to ACT ?

Raganadh Mishra commission report should be publish and put on table at parlement without any delay by the upa govt,