You can’t hold Kashmir at gunpoint: Mehbooba at NIC
By TCN News,
New Delhi: No people could be subjugated by force and Kashmir needed a humane and creative approach to resolve the problems facing it, People’s Democratic Party president Mehbooba Mufti has said. Speaking in the National Integration Council meeting chaired by Prime Minister here today Mehbooba also said that Indian Muslims need to be trusted.
“No people can be occupied at gunpoint and if anyone thinks Kashmir can be occupied by force he is wrong” former Jammu and Kashmir chief minister Mufti told the NIC meeting convened here by PM Dr Manmohan Singh.
According to the media statement from her PDP party, Mehbooba said “we in Kashmir still see India as a land of spiritualism and an abode of saints and Dervishes, something we have in common. Whatever is left of our relations it is because of this shared belief” she said urging the country’s leadership to build on these commonalities and provide justice and democratic space to people of Jammu & Kashmir.
Mehbooba said the situation in Kashmir has entered a new phase. The entire problem now revolves around one simple question. Are we ready to provide space for dissent within the system, she asked? The internal dimension of the issue demands an answer to that crucial though simple question. So far we have found that beyond the holding of elections no space for expression is allowed unless people say what the powers that be want to hear.
She said that unless the space for dissent is allowed, democracy in J&K will remain inadequate and flawed. And unless J&K is at peace with itself and with rest of the region, the idea of India will remain incomplete.
Opening her speech she condoled the deaths caused in the Delhi High Court blast and said: “We in Kashmir understand the pain and agony of its victims and their families more than anybody else.” She said Jammu & Kashmir has been in the vortex of similar mindless violence for decades but is unable to receive justice in spite of being part of a democratic India. She said acknowledgement of no fewer than 2700 graves of unknown Kashmiris by a state agency has been treated almost as routine news or no news at all by most of the media and political establishment. Can all of us here irrespective of our political beliefs muster courage to stand up and hang our heads in shame for these graves are not somewhere on the Mars or in a nondescript African country? They are here in Mahatama Gandhi’s India the largest democracy in the world and the purpose of this meeting would have been served in great measure if we hold out a promise of closure to those who are waiting unendingly for their loved ones. The state must do its duty to keep an account of its citizens even if they are dead and buried in unmarked graves.
Mehbooba said justice had been eluding Kashmir in spite of our best efforts to give democracy and non violence a full endorsement. Fake encounters are continuing in the state in spite of the Supreme Court orders to hang the culprits involved in such cases. She recounted the fake encounters staged recently including the ones at Surankote, of the 70 year old Habibullah Khan last year and Machhil encounters for money and medals and said not even the decade old Pathribal incident had been investigated properly. Similarly, none of the killers of 120 youth last year has been prosecuted or punished she said and pointed out that justice can’t be done selectively. She said those demanding punishment for Afzal Guru must join our demand for the criminals who committed crimes against Kashmiris as well.
On the issues facing Indian Muslims Mehbooba said one of the momentous decisions taken by UPA-1 was the appointment of Sachar Committee on minorities. It helped in redefining the minorities of India, especially the Muslims as facing huge problems of social growth and economic development rather than being a problem themselves. We believe it helped in changing the perspectives of national integration in relations between the state and the country’s largest minority group. But, she said, inadequacies in its follow up are too glaring to be missed.
Mehbooba said the crucial issue of Muslim representation in services is still unresolved. One would easily appreciate the miniscule Muslim representation in jobs that require higher academic qualifications but what does stop the state in making it equitable for them in even the menial jobs of peons or constables? She said a solution will have to be found to this to help at least some families sustain and grow to the next level of incremental emancipation.
One more development on the flip side, Mehbooba said is the response by the state agencies to the acts of terror. It is for some time now that the state agencies don’t reel out names of suspects almost simultaneously with the incident. This could have a salutary impact on minorities who otherwise were treated as natural suspects and suffered deep insecurities.
Mehbooba said though one is not comfortable with the realization that hardly any cases of bombings and terror have been solved in the past two years but it gives one some satisfaction as well that no innocents are hauled up in the name of cracking the cases almost without requiring any investigations. She said the release of the so called Mecca Masjid accused in Hyderabad stands out in bold relief against the continued imprisonment of Samjhauta Express blast suspects who continue to face prosecution in spite of confession statements by someone else. We hope the quality of investigation is improved further to spare the innocents even if it takes time to lay hand on the real culprits involved in these heinous crimes against humanity.
Narrating her own experiences Mehbooba said an ex diplomat of United States had told her that it was the Muslim minority of America that had helped their country avert a repetition of 9/11. She said unless the state and nation of India fully trusted its minorities the country could not fully integrate to fight the menace of terror.