Will women quota bill strengthen only political dynasties?
Submitted by admin4 on 9 March 2010 - 7:55pm
By Shafee Ahmed Ko, TwoCircles.net,
Chennai: Whether women reservation bill will only strengthen political dynasties in India is a fear that has strong ground in the political history of the country which has seen several political families rising and capturing political power. Even today there are a dozen odd families which have considerable presence in both state and national politics. The female members of such families are ahead in the grab.
At present there are 59 women MPs. Majority of them are from Congress and next majority from BJP. Out of 556 women candidates fielded in the 2009 general elections only 10% of them are successfully representing now. Our Lok Sabha Speaker, though from Dalit community, is five time winner. However, most women MPs are from high class political families.
On women's bill the worry is if all the 33% MPs are drawn from such dynasties where the lower echelon and downtrodden have to find electoral opportunities: Merit is agreed. When the 80% of population is lower classes, we are ruled by 15% upper classes and mention is to be made that out of this 15%, a particular group of 2% dominate the entire nation by virtue of merit and eliteness. How many years more will the 80% take to have merits and eliteness? To achieve 16% education (to read and write) uplifment, it has taken 60 years, how many year will India need to achieve advancement at par with all elite groups?
Have a look at some political families.
The Nehru-Gandhi Family
Motilal Nehru (1861-1931) (politician and lawyer) (Father)
Jawaharlal Nehru (1889-1964) (Prime Minister, 1947-1964) (Son of Motilal)
Kamala Nehru, (1899-1936) (wife of Jawaharlal, Congress leader)
Indira Gandhi (1917-1984) ( Prime Minister, 1966-1977 and 1980-1984) (Daughter of Jawaharlal)
Feroze Gandhi (1912-1960), (Member of Parliament)(Indira Gandhi’s husband)
Rajiv Gandhi (1944-1991) (Prime Minister, 1984-1989) (Son of Indira)
Sonia Gandhi, (1946-) (president of the Indian National Congress party) (Widow of Rajiv)
Rahul Gandhi (1970-) (Member of Parliament and a General Secretary of the Indian National Congress) - (Son of Rajiv)
Priyanka Gandhi (1974-) (Home Maker) - (Daughter of Rajiv)
Sanjay Gandhi (1946-1980) (politician) - (Son of Indira)
Maneka Gandhi (1956-) (politician, ex-minister, environmentalist) - (Widow of Sanjay) - (not of Congress party)
Varun Gandhi (1980-) (politician) - (Son of Sanjay) - (MP, BJP)
Vijaya Lakshmi Pandit, (1900-1990) (MP and diplomat) (daughter of Motilal)
Sheila Kaul, (1915-) (former Union Minister)(maternal aunt of Indira Gandhi)
Nayantara Sehgal, (novelist and political critic) (daughter of Mrs Pandit)
Uma Nehru (Member of Parliament) - (Indira’s cousin)
Arun Nehru (politician, ex-minister) - (Nephew of Indira, son of Uma) - (not of Congress party)
The Anugrah Narayan Sinha Family
Dr. Anugrah Narayan Sinha, (politician and first Deputy Chief Minister of Bihar)
Satyendra Narayan Sinha, Former Chief Minister of Bihar (Son of Dr Anugrah Narayan Sinha)
Kishori Sinha,(former Member Of Parliament)-(Wife Of Satyendra Narayan Sinha)
Rameshwar Prasad Sinha,(father of Kishori Sinha, Member Of Constituent Assembly)
Nikhil Kumar, Governor Of Nagaland (son of Satyendra Narayan Sinha)
Shyama Singh,(Ex MP) (Wife of Nikhil Kumar)
N. K. Singh, Rajya Sabha MP (Brother-in-law Of Nikhil Kumar)
Uday Singh, (Member Of Parliament)-(Nikhil Kumar’s younger brother in law)
Madhuri Singh,(former MP)-(Nikhil Kumar’s mother in law)
The Satpathy Family
Shri. Devendra Satpathy, Two times Lok Sabha MP from Orissa
Smt. Nandini Satpathy,Two times Rajya Sabha member,Union Minister,Chief Minister of Orissa
Shri. Tathagata Satpathy, Three times Lok Sabha MP from Orissa
Shri. Suparno Satpathy, Awarded Social Activist, noted writer,promising young political leader of Orissa
The Mishra Family
Lalit Narayan Mishra, Former Railway Minister of India
Vijay Kumar Mishra Ex MP, MLA and MLC and active politician in Bihar Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP (Son of Lalit Narayan Mishra)
Gouri Shankar Rajhans, Ex MP, Bihar (Husband of niece of Lalit Narayan Mishra)
Jagannath Mishra, Former Chief Minister and Union Cabinet Minister (Brother of Lalit Narayan Mishra)
Nitish Mishra, Ex Minister and MLA in Bihar (Son of Dr Jagannath Mishra)
The Ramachandran Family
M.G. Ramachandran, Chief Minister of Tamil Nadu
Janaki Ramachandran, Chief Minister of Tamil Nadu (wife of MGR)
The Karunanidhi Family
M. Karunanidhi, Chief Minister of Tamil Nadu
M.K. Stalin, Deputy Chief Minister of Tamil Nadu (Son of Karunanidhi)
M.K. Azhagiri, Union Minister for Chemicals and Fertilizers (Son of Karunanidhi)
Kanimozhi Member of Parliament, Rajya Sabha (Daughter of Karunanidhi)
Murasoli Maran, former union minister (nephew of Karunanidhi)
Dayanidhi Maran, Union Minister for Textiles (son of Maran)
The Abdullah Family
Sheikh Abdullah, Former Chief Minister of Jammu and Kashmir
Begum Akbar Jahan Abdullah, Member of Parliament (wife of Sheikh Abdullah)
Farooq Abdullah, Former Chief Minister of Jammu and Kashmir (son of Sheikh Abdullah)
Omar Abdullah, Chief Minister of Jammu and Kashmir, former Union Minister, (son of Farooq)
Sara Abdullah, (daughter of Farooq)
Sachin Pilot, Member of Parliament (husband of Sara)
Begum Khalida Shah, President of Awami National Conference, J&K State (daughter of Sheikh Abdullah)
Ghulam Mohammad Shah, Former Chief Minister of Jammu and Kashmir, (husband of Begum Khalida Shah)
Muzzafher Shah, Senior Vice President of Awami National Conference, J&K state (son of Ghulam Mohammed Shah)
The Owaisi Family
Abdul Wahed Owaisi
Sultan Salahuddin owaisi, Former Member of Parliament, Hyderabad.
Asaduddin Owaisi, Member of Parliament 2004 - Present
Akbaruddin Owaisi, MLA Andhra Pradesh
The Bahuguna Family
Hemvati Nandan Bahuguna, Former Chief Minister of Uttar Pradesh.
Vijay Bahuguna, Member of Parliament
Rita bahuguna Joshi President of UPCC.
The K. Karunakaran Family
K. Karunakaran, Kerala chief minister
K. Muraleedharan, Former State Minister for Electricity and Member of parliament (Son of Karunakaran)
Padmaja Venugopal, (Daughter of K. Karunakaran)
The Kodoth Family-Kodoth, Kerala India
Kodoth Krishnan Nair, State politician-assassinated
Kodoth Govindan Nair, Congress Politician, K. Karunakaran associate
The Ramadoss Family - Tamil Nadu, India
S. Ramadoss, PMK founder, Tamil Nadu Politician
Anbumani Ramadoss, Former Cabinet Minister, rajya Sabha MP
The Kumaramangalam Family (father-son and daughter)
P. Subbarayan (Chief Minister of Tamil Nadu)
Mohan Kumaramangalam (Indian National Congress cabinet minister)
Lalitha Kumaramangalam (Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) politician in Pondicherry)
Rangarajan Kumaramangalam (BJP cabinet minister)
The Naidu Family
Sarojini Naidu (freedom fighter and poetess) (Mother)
Padmaja Naidu (Governor) (Daughter)
The Mirdha Family of Rajasthan
Baldev Ram Mirdha
Ram Niwas Mirdha
Nathuram Mirdha
Harendra Mirdha
Richpal Mirdha
Raghuvendra Mirdha
The Patnaik Family
Biju Patnaik
Naveen Patnaik, son of Biju
Gita Mehta, daughter of Biju
The Pilot Family
Rajesh Pilot
Rama Pilot, wife of Rajesh Pilot
Sachin Pilot, son of Rajesh Pilot
Sara Abdullah Pilot, wife of Sachin Pilot and daughter of Farooq Abdullah
The Lalu Yadav Family
Laloo Prasad Yadav, former Bihar chief minister, former Railway minister
Rabri Devi, former Bihar chief minister
Sadhu Yadav,(former MP) Rabri Devi’s brother
Subhash Yadav,(Rajya Sabha MP)Rabri Devi’s brother
The Nandamuri Family
Nandamuri Taraka Rama Rao ”NTR”, Former Film Actor & Former chief minister of Andhra Pradesh
Laxmi Parvathy, Second wife of NTR, erstwhile leader of TDP (NTR) faction.
Nara Chandrababu Naidu, son-in-law of NTR, former chief minister of Andhra Pradesh
Nandamuri Harikrishna, son of NTR, Member Of Parliament, Ex Transport Minister.
Nandamuri Balakrishna, son of NTR, Recently Entered into Politics
Daggubati Purandareswari, Daughter of NTR, Minister of State, Human Resource Development
Daggubati Venkateswara Rao, son-in-law of NTR, Member of Andhra Pradesh State Assembly, Ex Member of Parliament, Ex Health Minister.
The Sayeed Family
Mufti Mohammad Sayeed, former Home Minister, India, ex-CM, J&K
Mehbooba Mufti, daughter of Mufti Muhammed
The Scindia Family (former Maharajas) (mother-son and daughters-grandsons)
Rajmata Vijayraje ScindiaBJP
Madhavrao Scindia, son of Vijayaraje INC
Jyotiraditya Scindia, son of Madhavrao
Vasundhara Raje Scindia, Chief minister of Rajasthan, daughter of Vijayaraje
Dushyant Singh, son of Vasundhara Raje
Yashodhara Raje Scindia, daughter of Vijayaraje
The Thackerary Family
Balasaheb Thackeray
Udhav Thackeray, son of Balasaheb
Smitha Thackeray, daughter-in-law of Balasaheb
Raj Thackeray, nephew of Balasaheb
The Pawar Family
Sharad Pawar, Agriculture Minister, India
Supriya Sule, daughter of Sharad Pawar, local politician
Ajit Pawar, nephew of Sharad Pawar Irrigation Minister, Maharashtra
The Chavan Family
Shankarrao Chavan, ex chief minister of Maharashtra, ex home minister of India
Ashok Chavan, current chief minister of Maharashtra
Bhaskarrao Bapurao Khatgaonkar, member of Lok Sabha of India
The Devegowda Family
Devegowda, Ex-Prime Minister, India; Ex-Chief minister Karnataka
H.D. Revanna, Son of Devegowda, Ex-minister Karnataka
H.D. Kumaraswamy, Son of Devegowda, Ex-Chief Minister Karnataka
The Y.S. Rajasekhara Reddy Family
Y.S. Rajasekhara Reddy,Ex-Chief minister, Andhra Pradesh
Y.S. Jagan Mohan Reddy, M.P Kadapa, Andhra Pradesh (son of Y.S. RajaSekahara Reddy )
Y.S. Vivekananda Reddy,Ex-M.P Kadapa, Andhra Pradesh ( Brother of Y.S. RajaShekara Reddy)
The Mulayam Singh Yadav Family
Mulayam Singh Yadav Ex-Chief Minister Uttar Pradesh.
Akhilesh Yadav,Member of ParliamentSon.
The Chautala Family
Chaudhari Devi Lal (1914-2001) (Deputy Prime Minister of India, 1989-1991), (Chief Minister of Haryana, 1977-1979 and 1987-1989) (Father)
Ch. Om Prakash Chautala (Ex-Chief Minister of Haryana)(Son)
Abhay Chautala MP (Grandson)
Ajay Chautala MP (Grandson)
The Bansilal Family
Chaudhari Bansilal Former Chief Minister of Haryana, Defence Minister of India, Railway Minister of India
Surendar Chaudary Member of Parliament,(Son)
Ranbir Mahender Ex President BCCI, MLA (Son)
Kiran Chaudhary Ex Depy Speaker Delhi Assembly, Ex MoS Haryana (Daughter-in-Law)
Shruti Chaudhary MP Bhiwani (Granddaughter)
The Naik Family
Ganesh Naik, Minister of State excise and non conventional energy,Maharashtra
Sanjeev Naik , Member of Parliament
Sandeep Naik , Member of Legislative Assembly
Late Tukaram Naik ,EX-Leader of opposition , Navi Mumbai Municipal Corporation
FREE REPRINTS
Unless otherwise noted, you can republish our articles for free. You just have to credit TwoCircles.net and link it back to us, and you can’t edit our material or sell it separately. (We're licensed under Creative Commons, which provides the legal details.). For publishing TwoCircles.net photos please contact info@twocircles.net.
If you feel strongly against
If you feel strongly against the disregard for merit in Indian political system, if you feel that you have seen enough of “dynasty politics” then it’s this is your chance to do something about it. Even more so if you are a Navi Mumbaikar since the recent happenings displays oligarchy at its worst.
Then PLEASE SIGN THE PETITION by clicking the following link.
www.ipetitions.com/petition/navimumbai/
devegowda family
Kumarswamy's wife mrs Anita kumaraswamy is left. She is an MLA from Madur constituency.
By Shafee Ahmed Ko persists with his trainer's default
Shafee Ahmed Ko presented good information but i must say that he is persisting with his defaults set by his trainers, if he had few. His reference to name with common names instead of real on, e.g Mufti Muhammad Saeed as Mufti Mohammed and Sayeed.
I must declare here that he is of no use as is the case with Mr Javed Akhtar, who instead of commenting on women reservation and the reservations of Muslims on this, talked nonsense like divorce etc. Though bad, divorce is not the biggest problem of Muslims while marriage is. Though he is a sworn non-Muslim, how media presents him as one shows the intention of the media. Does non-Muslims expects Muslims to accept this type of people as 'intellectuals' of the community who just want to dig rot instead of suggesting cleaning it. There is no denying that there is a rot and mere digging is not the way to clear it. The sadist criticism by weak hearted Muslim after 1947 is more problematic than many well meaning Hindus who are default humane. You cant expect them to do more for you than you yourself are doing. The accusation of 'appeasement' also falls under this.
PS: The many newspresenters in e-media studios does not mean that Muslim participation has been established. They are like the 'soldiers of Israel' palestinian origins elogised by media for denigrating the Palestinian cause.
Hindu ladies inheritance act was enacted in 2005 only while it should take atleast 100 years to be implemented. How India expects the poorer sections to have rights, is not after 150 more years.
Women Reservation Bill and Indian Muslims
The day of March 09,may be the historic but for Indian muslims,OBC and others, this day brought the message of political destruction.For the muslims whose representation decreasing with the passage of time(Less than 50 M.P.)both at the centre and State level,this Bill proves another deliberate dagger striking.In present time ,the indian muslims are far behind in the political power sharing with other communities.The muslims of India would not opposed this bill if there would be certain provisions for them.
1 Reservation of certain seats for Muslim women .
2 Provision in the political parties to reserve their ceratin paercentage of seats for minorities,OBC etc.
Now the Bill has been passed by Rajya Sabha,the muslims with other communties should try to ensure that:
1 The reserved seats for women should not be muslim majority constituencies.
2 There should be watch on the name list of the political parties for women reserved seats.
3 To support the regional parties of their respective states both for the state goverment and centre.
4 No love for any political party for granted.
5 To set up a committee to analysis the damage from women reservation bill to muslims political power.
shameful day for democracy/ congress showing true colors
Cong+ BJP+ Left is projecting opposition to bill in current form as opponents of women and their interest.
In fact they are talking about women who are bottom of social ladder. These elite and rich do not want those to come in parliament.
In the name of women quota, upper cast has secured 1/3 seats in parliament.
This was done in most undemocratic manner by issuing whips and sonia acted as dictator.
Today Marshels entered in Parliament, tommorow Martial Law/ emergency.
Congress showing its true colours.
Cong+ BJP + Left are anti dalits, lower class and minority.
Minority can NOT hold majority to ransom
In a democracy MINORITY can not hold the majority to ransom by spreading violence. Minority can express their opinion but must allow everyone else also express their opinion too. That is democracy. But when 7-8 MPs try to hold the RAJYA SABHA to ransom, they just have to be thrown out. It is a bit like TERRORIST with AK47 holding hostages- the MPs may not have AK47 but they were resorting to violence.
If a few HINDUTVA fanatics obstruct a religious festival of MUSLIMS would it be acceptable? Wouldn't the affected Muslims request police protection? it is same case here too. The "anti-womens bill fanatics" obstructed the rajya sabha and they had to be expelled by rajya sabha police.
whipocracy in the name of democracy
It is unfortunate that only these minority member are representing Majority population (close to 80%).
What kind of democracy is this, in which agenda and wish of one person(sonia) was forced on people without taking care of concern of majority. No all party meeting was called b4 voting.
What is use of whip in democracy? Is this not the tool for dictator?
They should have voted without whip.
same was not said in Shah Bano case.
same was not said in Shah Bano case and a MUSLIM MINISTER resigned on the issue but Mr Rajiv Gandhi rammed the constitutional amendment with his 3/4 majority.
Post new comment